← All chapters
Volume X

Extra Grace Required

Extra Grace Required

Thursday, June 19, 2025.

Priya always drove. This was established fact, as fixed as her preference for window seats and her inability to leave a voicemail under two minutes. Miri had stopped questioning it somewhere around sophomore year, when she realized that riding shotgun meant she could watch the landscape without pretending to watch the road.

They'd left Millbrook before seven, the morning still holding that blue-gray quality that made everything feel provisional. Priya's car smelled like the lavender sachets her mother tucked into every available crevice, a scent Miri associated with Sunday dinners at the Sharma household, Priya's father explaining cricket with patient futility—and belonging to something without having to explain how.

"You're quiet," Priya said, forty minutes into the drive.

"I'm always quiet."

"You're quiet-quiet. Different animal."

Miri shifted in her seat. The stone from Lake Aurelia was in her pocket; she'd taken to carrying it without quite deciding to. "Just thinking about the visit."

"Liar." Priya said it without heat. "But okay. Think away."

Whitmore College was two hours northeast, a small liberal arts school tucked into hills that reminded Miri of home but sharper, more deliberate in their beauty. She'd found it during one of her late-night searches, drawn by something in the campus photos. Not the buildings themselves, though they were pretty enough. The way people were arranged in them. Small groups on lawns. A girl reading alone under a tree. Spaces that looked like they might hold silence without making it strange.

She hadn't told anyone about those searches—how she zoomed in on faces, trying to read expressions.


They stopped for gas and bad coffee at a station that sold hunting licenses and live bait. Priya emerged from the convenience store with two cups and a package of mini donuts, which she tossed to Miri through the open window.

"Breakfast of champions."

"These are entirely synthetic."

"Your point being?"

Miri opened the package. The donuts were waxy and too sweet, and she ate three of them before they reached the highway again.

"My mom keeps sending me articles about this place," Priya said, merging into sparse traffic. "Their psychology department, specifically. She's not subtle."

"She never is."

"Last week she left a printout on my bed. Just casually. 'Oh, I thought you might find this interesting.' It was a ranking of graduate school placement rates."

"She loves you."

"She loves me with an agenda." But Priya was smiling. "Your parents doing the same thing?"

Miri thought of her father at the kitchen table, the careful way he'd talked about her mother's questions. The permission he'd given her to not answer them. "They're giving me space."

"That sounds healthy and also terrifying."

"It's both."

The highway opened up, fields on either side turning gold in the strengthening light. Miri watched a hawk circle over a barn, patient and precise. She thought about her nightstand: the stone, the acceptance letter she still hadn't responded to, the small wooden box where she kept things that mattered. Her mother's first note to her, written on the day they met. A pressed flower from a hike with her father. A photograph of herself at three days old, held by hands that would let her go.

She didn't know what she was building in that box. Only that she kept adding to it.

Whitmore College — Late Morning

The campus was quieter than the photos had promised—summer session, Miri realized, watching a handful of students cross the quad where dozens had gathered in the brochure shots. But the bones were right: brick and green and purposefully imperfect. A student guide named Marcus led them through buildings and courtyards, narrating history and statistics with the ease of someone who'd done this a hundred times without getting bored. Miri listened with half her attention, the other half cataloging details: the way students moved between classes, the sounds from open windows, the particular quality of light in the library.

Outside the student services office, Marcus gestured toward a bulletin board. "Tons of scholarship opportunities. Merit-based, need-based, identity-based. Whatever your situation."

Miri's eyes caught on a purple flyer, bottom corner curling slightly. Adoptee Achievement Scholarship. Supporting students who have experienced adoption in building their futures.

She looked away. Then looked back.

The flyer had a photograph: a young woman in a graduation cap, smiling at someone outside the frame. Underneath, bullet points about eligibility, application requirements, essay prompts. Tell us about your adoption story and how it has shaped your educational journey.

Miri felt something shift in her chest. Not discomfort exactly. Recognition, maybe. Or resistance to recognition.

"You coming?" Priya was three steps ahead, looking back.

"Yeah." Miri took a folder from the stack below the bulletin board, slipped the purple flyer inside without examining why. "Coming."


The information session was in a room with too many windows, afternoon light making everyone squint. An admissions officer talked about "fit" and "community" and "the whole person," phrases that washed over Miri like water she was learning not to drown in.

Priya took notes. She always took notes. Her handwriting was small and precise, filling pages with observations Miri knew she'd never look at again. The act of writing was the point, not the record.

Afterward, they wandered. This was the part of college visits Miri liked best: the unstructured time, the chance to feel a place rather than be told about it. They found a bench near a pond that was really just a large fountain with pretensions, and sat watching students pass in the afternoon sun.

"Could you see yourself here?" Priya asked.

Miri considered. The campus was beautiful. The people seemed engaged without being manic about it. She could imagine walking these paths, sitting in these chairs, becoming some version of herself that had answers to the questions adults kept asking.

But she could also imagine being somewhere else. Anywhere else. The future felt less like a destination and more like fog she was walking into, trusting that something solid would eventually appear.

"Maybe," she said. "You?"

Priya didn't answer. A small group of summer students was crossing the lawn—three or four of them, backpacks and easy laughter. One of them, a girl with a red bag, walked slightly apart from the others. Not excluded exactly. Just not quite included.

Miri glanced at Priya. Something had changed in her face.

"Priya?"

"I'm fine." The automatic response. Then, quieter: "I'm not fine. Can we walk?"


They walked. Away from the main quad, past dormitories with propped-open doors, through a parking lot that led to a small grove of trees at the campus edge. The sounds of the college faded. It was cooler here, the light filtered and green.

Priya stopped at a wooden bench that looked like it hadn't been sat on in years. She didn't sit. Just stood, arms crossed, staring at something Miri couldn't see.

"Those students back there," Priya said. "The ones crossing the lawn."

"What about them?"

"One of them—the girl with the red bag—she reminded me of someone."

Miri waited. She'd learned that waiting was a language Priya understood.

"There was a girl. At Friends." Priya's voice had gone flat, the way it did when she was controlling something. "She was in our year. She left sophomore spring—do you remember her?"

Miri tried to place her. A big girl, maybe. Someone she'd seen without looking at.

"What was her name?"

"I don't—" Priya stopped. Started again. "I don't actually know if I ever used it."

She sat down on the bench, suddenly, as if her legs had made the decision without her. Miri sat beside her, close enough that their shoulders almost touched. Not quite. The space between them was its own kind of language.

"You know the type. Extra grace required." Priya's mouth twisted. "The kid who needs more patience. More understanding. It sounds generous when you say it that way."

Miri knew the type. She'd been in enough Meetings to recognize the quiet sigh when certain people rose to speak.

"But really it just means the kid everyone finds exhausting. The one who doesn't read social cues. Who talks too loud, too long, about things nobody cares about. Who doesn't understand when she's not wanted."

The words came faster now, as if something had been dammed up behind them.

"She was fat. And loud. She took up space. Physical space, conversational space. She had a stutter, not bad but noticeable, and she'd push through it instead of pausing, so conversations with her felt like endurance tests. She'd overshare constantly. Her parents' divorce. Things you don't tell people until you know them, except she didn't seem to know there was a difference between people you know and people you're still learning."

Priya was looking at her hands now, fingers laced tight.

"A Quaker school. 'That of God in everyone.' Holding people in the light." Priya's voice was bitter. "But I just—"

She stopped. Miri waited.

"I made her invisible. My friends and I—the lunch table crowd, before you and I got close." She glanced at Miri. "You were always off in the library somewhere."

Miri nodded. She had been.

"Not all at once. Not obviously. No one was ever mean to her face. I just... stopped including her. Stopped inviting her. When she'd come up to our table, the conversation would die. Not freeze, not go hostile. Just... evaporate. I'd become terribly interested in my phone, or remember something I needed to do. She'd stand there for a minute, trying, and then she'd leave. And I'd resume."

Priya's voice cracked, then steadied. "I told myself I wasn't the worst one. I wasn't the one who organized the party she wasn't invited to. I wasn't the one who moved seats when she sat down. I just... didn't object. Didn't say anything. Let it happen."

A bird called somewhere in the trees. The light through the leaves was green and quiet.

"She disappeared, eventually. Stopped showing up. I heard she transferred. I heard she was homeschooled. I heard she had a breakdown. Nobody actually knew because nobody asked." Priya finally looked at Miri. Her eyes were dry, but her face held something worse than tears. "I was relieved, Miri. When she was gone. I was relieved that I didn't have to feel guilty about not talking to her anymore, because she wasn't there to not talk to."

Miri absorbed this. Let it sit in her the way things sat in water, sinking slowly to the bottom.

"And now?" she asked.

"Now I'm sitting on a college campus, watching students be young and stupid and careless with each other, and I'm wondering if she's okay. If she ever was okay. If she's even—" Priya's breath caught. "I don't know if she's alive, Miri. I don't know what happened to her. I was relieved when she left, and I never thought about her again until right now, and I don't know if she's alive."

The silence between them expanded, filled the grove, pressed against the trees.

Miri did not say you were young. Did not say it wasn't your fault. Did not offer the easy absolution that would let Priya set this down before she'd really held it.

Instead, she sat. Let her shoulder finally touch Priya's, the smallest contact. Held the space the way her father held space, the way Meeting held space: open, patient, without demand.

Priya was crying now, quiet tears that she didn't wipe away. "I've never told anyone. Not once. Not in three years."

"I know."

"You're not going to tell me it's okay?"

"No."

"Good." Priya laughed, watery and strange. "I don't think I could stand it if you did."

They sat until the tears dried on Priya's face, until the whatever-it-was that had cracked open began to close again. Not heal—healing was a longer word than either of them had right now. But close. Settle. Become bearable.

The Drive Home — Evening

The drive home was different.

Priya put on music, something quiet and ambient that asked nothing of them. Miri watched the landscape reverse itself, fields and highways and the slow accumulation of familiar landmarks. The lavender smell of the car felt like permission.

At some point, Priya said: "Thank you. For not making it better."

Miri nodded. She understood, in a way she couldn't yet articulate, that this was the thing. Not solving. Not fixing. Not explaining away. Just staying.

It was harder than she'd imagined, holding someone's guilt. Grief was one thing—grief could be witnessed, honored, accompanied. But guilt was different. Guilt wanted absolution, and withholding that absolution, even when it was the right thing to do, felt almost like cruelty. It required something of her that she hadn't known she had.

In her bag, the purple flyer waited. Tell us about your adoption story and how it has shaped your educational journey.

She didn't know her adoption story. Didn't know if she wanted to. Didn't know if claiming it—officially, on paper, for scholarship money—would be honoring the truth or commodifying it.

But she knew something else now. Knew it the way she knew the weight of the stone in her pocket, the sound of silence at Quaker Meeting, the two languages her family spoke without ever switching tongues.

She could hold things. Heavy things. The things people couldn't say until they could, and then had nowhere to put down.

Maybe that was something.

Maybe that was enough to begin.